The Right to Repair
Miles NortonA case for ownersEnglish 2500

You bought it. You should get to fix it.

Companies decide who gets the parts, tools, and manuals. Repair laws would hand that choice back to owners.

Share of people surveyed who support laws requiring access to repair parts, tools, software updates, and instructions

Survey of 838 U.S. consumers (Perzanowski 387).

Owners expect to repair what they own

A phone or laptop is a big purchase on a student budget. People assume they can fix one when it breaks, and they hold it against the product when they can't. In a survey of 838 U.S. consumers, more than 70 percent said repair restrictions would make them less likely to buy a device (Perzanowski 384-85).

“The high costs of repairs and the limited availability of parts and tools are significant barriers.”Perzanowski 388

Support for a legal fix is wide. Eighty-six percent backed laws on parts, tools, software updates, and instructions, and among people who already knew the issue well that figure reached 98 percent (387).

What 838 U.S. consumers said about repair
Less likely to buy a device that has repair restrictions
70%+
Support laws requiring access to parts, tools, updates, and instructions
86%
Support among respondents very familiar with the right to repair
98%

Source: Perzanowski 384-87. The first bar is a floor: the survey reports “more than 70 percent.”

Regulators and researchers have been at this for a decade

2015The FTC settles with BMW over tying warranty coverage to its own parts and service (Federal Trade Commission 8).
2019Legal scholars conclude that intellectual property law should accommodate repair (Grinvald and Tur-Sinai 63).
2020A survey of 838 consumers finds 86 percent support for repair access laws (Perzanowski 387).
2021The FTC tells Congress there is “scant evidence” behind manufacturers' reasons for restricting repair (6).
2023The Nokia G22 ships, “engineered to be repaired in minutes” (Ozturkcan).
January 2026More than 33 repair bills are introduced in 13 states within a few weeks (Quinn).

Thirteen statehouses took it up in one month

In the first few weeks of January 2026, lawmakers in 13 states introduced more than 33 right-to-repair bills, and advocates expect action on electronics, tractors, cars, and mobility devices (Quinn).

States with repair bills introduced, January 2026
13 of 50 states

Source: Quinn.

Bills introduced in those weeks
33+
  • Electronics
  • Tractors
  • Cars
  • Mobility devices

Source: Quinn.

Manufacturers give three reasons. Here is how each holds up.

Intellectual property

What manufacturers say
Repair manuals and diagnostic software cost money to create. Being forced to share them feels like giving that work away.
What the research found
Grinvald and Tur-Sinai tested how each area of IP law could block repair and concluded that “intellectual property law should accommodate consumers' right to repair their products” (63).
Areas of IP law the authors examined
PatentCopyrightTrademarkTrade secret

Safety

What manufacturers say
People who don't know how to repair their equipment properly could get hurt (Quinn).
What the FTC found
“Manufacturers provided no data to support their argument that injuries are tied to repairs” (28). The report does not claim every repair is safe. It says the claim has not been backed up.
Injury data manufacturers gave the FTC linking repairs to injuries

This chart is empty on purpose (Federal Trade Commission 28).

Digital security

What manufacturers say
Opening up repair tools and software could create security problems (Quinn).
What the evidence shows
The FTC found most of these claims unsound (Ozturkcan). A law can allow a targeted protection where a company shows a real risk and still leave repair open to everyone else.
Years of security updates Google promises while selling spare parts through iFixit

Source: Ozturkcan.

A fair warning

Not every researcher agrees repair laws help. Ozturkcan describes a 2023 study estimating that a right-to-repair law could bring higher prices and a greater environmental impact for some products. It is one estimate, and it is a reason to care how each bill is written.

What can't be fixed gets thrown out

The FTC found that repair restrictions push people to replace products “before the end of their useful lives” (6). Each early replacement adds to the pile of electronic waste.

Recyclers back repair laws for this reason. They see them as a way to keep e-scrap out of disposal and cut down on lithium-ion battery fires (Quinn).

Phone makers show both paths. One company can allow repair on paper and still make it impractical, while another designs a phone to be opened. That gap is why voluntary programs are not enough.

Apple's Self Service Repair kit next to the battery it replaces, drawn to scale by weight

Area is proportional to weight. The kit weighs about 1,149 times as much as the battery (Ozturkcan).

Minutes to swap a part on the Nokia G22
Battery
~5
Screen
~20

Shown against one hour. Source: Ozturkcan.

Four phone makers, four different answers (Ozturkcan)
HMD (Nokia)Sells affordable parts through iFixitBuilt the G22 to be repaired in minutes.
GoogleSells spare parts through iFixitAlso promises five years of security updates.
SamsungRuns a repair program with iFixitLeft out parts for its newest flagship phones.
AppleRan its own Self Service Repair programCritics called the experience “a far cry from ease and sustainability.”

What you can do

Laws should require manufacturers to share parts, tools, and manuals with the people who own the device. You can push that along without picking up a screwdriver.

  • Back a repair bill

    Find out whether your state has one this session and tell your representatives you support it.

  • Check repairability before you buy

    Phone makers treat repair very differently. Look at who sells parts for a device before you pay for it.

  • Try the fix first

    Before you replace something, look it up. iFixit sells parts for many devices.

Works cited

Grinvald, Leah Chan, and Ofer Tur-Sinai. “Intellectual Property Law and the Right to Repair.” Fordham Law Review, vol. 88, no. 1, 2019, pp. 63-127.

Ozturkcan, Selcen. “The Right-to-Repair Movement: Sustainability and Consumer Rights.” Journal of Information Technology Teaching Cases, vol. 14, no. 2, 2024, pp. 217-23, https://doi.org/10.1177/20438869231178037.

Perzanowski, Aaron. “Consumer Perceptions of the Right to Repair.” Indiana Law Journal, vol. 96, no. 2, 2021, pp. 361-94. EBSCOhost, research.ebsco.com/plink/3f0749f5-c513-35ab-a311-28cbe68b3c1a.

Quinn, Megan. “Right-to-Repair Bills Make a Comeback in 2026.” Waste Dive, 20 Jan. 2026, www.wastedive.com/news/right-to-repair-bills-2026-electronics-automotbiles-wheelchairs/809993/.

United States, Federal Trade Commission. Nixing the Fix: An FTC Report to Congress on Repair Restrictions. May 2021, www.ftc.gov/reports/nixing-fix-ftc-report-congress-repair-restrictions.